Dilemma of Indian Agriculture

-


Farm laws are the most burning issue not in India but in the whole world. But most of us are not sure what actually is the problem and who are the stakeholders. Let's get directly to the point. The Government of India passed farm laws in November 2020. There are 3 laws or we can say acts. One says that there is no limit on holding, second says that farmers can sell their produce anywhere there, is no restriction of district mandis and the last one relates to the contract farming laws in India.

But the one thing that is creating furore is the absence of clause related to MSP in the laws. The situation is that farmers don't have bargaining power because their produce is very perishable and thus they have to sell their produce within one week of harvest, in case of wheat-rice especially. Thus, MSP was serving as a as an anchor for farmers to have a selling price which is covering the cost of cultivation.

But with the scrapping of this MSP, the farmers have even lost that last element of bargaining and this can be said as the last nail in the coffin. In India production of grains is ample and there are very less chances of shortage on supply side. Therefore, with the passing of these farm laws, corporates will be able to buy the production from farmers directly and without any supply shortage and obligation of MSP. Thus, these laws are considered as black laws for farmers. Though on long term, these are very much needed because for an open economy to survive there must be an open market and there must be competition. But these open market and open competition situations have come from western markets, where there is homogeneity in the market in terms of number of crops being sold and the supply side is also very much informed and technologically advanced. Also the farmers in this western markets are large farmers and they've got storage technologies as well as information regarding the market and thus they can exercise a good degree of bargaining power. That's where the whole problem lies. Now the Indian government thinks that this western ideology of development of open market and competition will develop the Indian agriculture but the factors are different in Indian market. Also, in developed markets, farmers get a lot of subsidy that gives them question cushion, and they don't need any kind of MSP. Every developed or developing market in the world have some kind of protection given to the farmers. But in case of India, these laws were passed without any protection for the farmers. Here 84% of farmers are small and marginal farmers and in terms of bargaining power considering perishability, even large and corporate farms can’t exercise bargaining power. That's why farmers are demanding for MSP to be made as a law. This situation is unprecedented because the whole world has eyes on India as India may become the first country where MSP can be made a law. This law will serve as universal basic income for farmers. If India pioneers in this case, then the farmers in the whole world will demand for this MSP as a law in their respective countries and industrial and Silicon development have degraded the environment so much that it's high time that we give a look towards the sustainable businesses that is agriculture. Apart from these problems, the laws were passed without any due debate in the parliament and they were passed in such a hurry that even if they would have been valid they would they should not have been passed at all because it is a threat to democracy.

Government is trying to curb this protest in any way possible. They tried to give it a name of Khalistan backed movement, then they tried to showcase that the farmers that are protesting are very rich and they have backing from Congress, they tried to instigate violence at some places and the person who hosted the saffron flag, that was even misrepresentation of facts that he threw the flag of India, also some even say that he had some connections to BJP. There are even messages circulating on the WhatsApp saying that Saudi Arabia is also a country where there is no farming and still they are a developed country with high growth rates.


These are propagandas spread by different parties. This protest is a flowing river and everyone will wash their hands for free (Behati Ganga). The recent support from Rihanna and Thunberg has made this protest a global protest. The hardcore followers of the BJP have tried every skill they can use to link Rihanna to Khalistan and Pakistan. These farm laws  showcase the two visions of development one is western and another one is the Indian development where the profits are not only the sole criteria of development but the people and their prosperity in terms of the food they eat how much happy they are etc. Now it's our choice, whether we want to choose western development as a reference line or not. If you think yes west is development then farm laws are a good choice and if not then no.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

INTRODUCTION TO FLOWER STRUCTURE

-
Image
INFLORESCENCE 1. Racemose : Inflorescence with monopodoal branching i.e., the inflorescence axis continues to grow and gives off lateral and axillary flowers. (i) Raceme: Racemose inflorescence having a common axis and stalked flowers arranged in acropetal succession, e.g., Brassica. (ii) Panicle: Axis of raceme is branched. (iii) Spike: Inflorescence is similar to raceme but the flowers are sessile: e.g., Achyranthes aspera. (iv) Spikelet: Very small spike of a compound spike forming a unit; e.g., grasses. (v) Catkin (or Ament) : A pendulous spike or spike-like inflorescence consisting of small unisexual flowers ; e.g., Morus alba. (vi) Spadix : A spike with thick and fleshy axis covered by a large spathe ; e.g., Maize. (vii) Corymb : It is a modified raceme with relatively a short main axis, in which the lower flowers have much elongated pedicels so that the flowers come to the same level ; e.g., Candytuft. (viii) Umbel : It is a modified raceme, in which the flowers have
Read more

MATURITY INDICES, HARVESTING AND POST HARVEST HANDLING OF FRUITS AND VEGETABLES

-
I. MATURITY It is the stage of fully development of tissue of fruit and vegetables only after which it will ripen normally. During the process of maturation the fruit receives a regular supply of food material from the plant. When mature, the abscission or corky layer which forms at the stern end stops this inflow. Afterwards, the fruit depend on its own reserves, carbohydrates are dehydrated and sugars accumulate until the sugar acid ratio form. In addition to this, typical flavour and characteristic colour also develop. it has been determined that the stage of maturity at the time of picking influence the storage life and quality of fruit, when picked immature like mango develop white patches or air pockets during ripening and lacking in normal brix acid ratio or sugar acid ratio, taste and flavour on the other hand if the fruits are harvested over mature or full ripe they are easy susceptible to microbial and physiological spoilage and their storage life is considerably reduce. Su
Read more

Concord or Subject-Verb Agreement

-
Collins English Dictionary defines Concord as “the way that a word has a form  appropriate  to the number or  gender  of the  noun  or  pronoun  it relates to. For  example , in 'She  hates  it', there is concord between the  singular  form of the  verb  and the singular pronoun 'she'.” Concord means harmony, an agreement or to be at peace. It has been derived from the Latin word concordis, con means the same and cordis is heart ; which indicates perfect harmony. In grammar, the subject and the verb have to be in perfect harmony. Its French version is concorde which also means the same . In English grammar, Concord mainly focuses on subject-verb agreement. This is subdivided into three categories: Grammatical concord Concord of proximity Notional concord Grammatical Concord The concept of singular verb with singular subject and plural verb with plural subject, in grammar, is called grammatical concord . The grand rule of subject-verb concord is that a s
Read more

Weeds

-
Image
W eeds are plants that are unwanted in a given situation and may be harmful, dangerous or economically detrimental. Weeds are a serious threat to primary production and biodiversity. They reduce farm and forest productivity, displace native species and contribute significantly to land and water degradation. The costs of weeds to the natural environment are also high, with weed invasion being ranked second only to habitat loss in causing biodiversity decline. Despite considerable government and private sector investment, weed invasion still represents a major threat to both the productive capacity of land and water and the integrity of our natural ecosystems. An efficient weed control program can only be developed after the weed has been properly identified. Weeds can be managed using many different methods. The most effective management of weeds is usually achieved through collaboration and cooperation, in partnerships between the community, land owners, agriculture, industry and the
Read more

Pool of Issues of Argumnet - Part 1

-
Image
This page contains the Argument topics for the Analytical Writing section of the   GRE ® revised General Test. When you take the test, you will be presented with one Argument topic from this pool. Each Argument topic consists of a passage that presents an argument followed by specific task instructions that tell you how to analyze the argument. The wording of some topics in the test might vary slightly from what is presented here. Also, because there may be multiple versions of some topics with similar or identical wording but with different task instructions, it is very important to read your test topic and its specific task directions carefully and respond to the wording as it appears in the actual test. Woven baskets characterized by a particular distinctive pattern have previously been found only in the immediate vicinity of the prehistoric village of Palea and therefore were believed to have been made only by the Palean people. Recently, however, archaeologists discovered s
Read more